In road construction, pavement plays a crucial role in ensuring durability, strength, and comfort for users. Depending on the requirements, engineers choose between two major types: flexible pavement and rigid pavement. Both have their own advantages, disadvantages, and specific areas of application. In this blog, we explore what each pavement type means, how they are used, and how they differ from one another.

What is Pavement?

Pavement refers to the uppermost layer of a road structure designed to carry traffic load and distribute it to the sub-base and subgrade beneath. It provides a smooth and durable surface for vehicles and helps protect the underlying layers from moisture and erosion. A well-constructed pavement ensures safety, comfort, and low maintenance for road users.

Difference Between Flexible and Rigid Pavement

What is Rigid Pavement?

Rigid pavement is made using cement concrete and sometimes reinforced concrete slabs. It acts as a single solid unit that distributes the traffic load over a wide area. Unlike flexible pavement, rigid pavement has a high modulus of elasticity, meaning it does not deform much under pressure.

Building Materials Used in Rigid Pavement:

• Ordinary Portland Cement (OPC) – for strength and binding

• Coarse Aggregates – like crushed stone or gravel

• Fine Aggregates – clean sand for smooth mix

• Water – clean and potable for mixing

• Reinforcement Steel – in case of RCC pavements

• Admixtures – like plasticisers for workability improvement

• Joint fillers and sealants – for expansion joints

Characteristics of Rigid Pavement:

• High flexural strength
• Long lifespan (20–30 years or more)
• Requires joints for expansion and contraction
• Load distribution is through slab action

Applications of Rigid Pavement

Rigid pavement is ideal for locations with high traffic load and where long-term durability is a priority. Common applications include:

• National highways and expressways
• Airport runways and taxiways
• Container terminals and ports
• Bus terminals and industrial roads
• Toll plazas and busy intersections

Its high strength and durability make it suitable for heavy-duty use.

What is Flexible Pavement?

Flexible pavement is made using bituminous materials (asphalt) over a base and sub-base layer. It bends and flexes under load, which is why it is called flexible. The load is distributed from the surface layer to the layers below gradually.

Characteristics of Flexible Pavement:

• Made of bitumen, asphalt or tar
• Lower initial cost
• More adaptable to minor subgrade settlement
• Requires more maintenance over time

Building Materials Used in Flexible Pavement:

• Bitumen/Asphalt – binding agent for surface layer

• Aggregates – both coarse (gravel, crushed stone) and fine (sand)

• Filler Material – stone dust or lime for stability

• Tack Coat/Prime Coat – bitumen emulsion for bonding layers

• Sub-base/Base Material – granular sub-base (GSB), water-bound macadam (WBM), or wet mix macadam (WMM)

• Geotextiles or stabilisers – optional, for strength improvement

Applications of Flexible Pavement

Flexible pavement is widely used for regular roadways with moderate traffic. It is suitable for:

• Rural roads and village roads
• Urban streets and city roads
• Temporary construction routes
• Parking areas
• Residential and township roads

Flexible pavement is preferred in areas where quick construction and lower cost are important.

Advantages of Flexible Pavement

• Quick and easy to lay
• Low initial construction cost
• Easily repairable and extendable
• Suitable for low to medium traffic volumes

Disadvantages of Flexible Pavement:

• Needs frequent maintenance
• Prone to cracks and potholes
• Life expectancy is shorter
• Bitumen is affected by temperature changes

Advantages of Rigid Pavement

• High strength and load capacity
• Durable with longer service life
• Less maintenance needed
• Performs better in extreme weather conditions

Disadvantages of Rigid Pavement:

• High initial construction cost
• Difficult to repair if damaged
• Requires skilled labour and machinery
• Expansion joints need regular inspection

IS Codes for Flexible Pavement

1. IRC:37-2018
   “Guidelines for the Design of Flexible Pavements”

   • Provides design methodology based on traffic loading and subgrade strength (CBR method).

2. IRC:81-1997
   “Guidelines for Strengthening of Flexible Road Pavements Using Benkelman Beam Deflection Technique”

   • Used for overlay design of existing pavements.

3. IS 73:2013
   “Paving Bitumen – Specification”

   • Covers different grades of paving bitumen used in flexible pavements.

4. IS 215:1995
   “Road Tar – Specification”

   • Applicable for tars used in surface dressing and bituminous construction.

5. IS 15462:2004
   “Emulsified Bitumen – Specification”

   • Used in cold mix and surface treatments.

📘 IS Codes for Rigid Pavement

1. IRC:58-2015
   “Guidelines for the Design of Plain Jointed Rigid Pavements for Highways”

   • Main design code for concrete pavements on highways.

2. IS 456:2000
   “Code of Practice for Plain and Reinforced Concrete”

   • General concrete guidelines, also applicable to rigid pavements.

3. IS 10262:2019
   “Guidelines for Concrete Mix Design Proportioning”

   • Required for designing concrete mix for rigid pavements.

4. IS 2386 (Part I to VIII):1963
   “Methods of Test for Aggregates for Concrete”

   • Covers testing methods for aggregates used in pavement concrete.

5. IS 516:1959
   “Method of Tests for Strength of Concrete”

   • Used for compressive strength and flexural strength testing.

General IS/IRC Codes Useful for Pavement Works

1. IRC:SP:76-2015
   “Guidelines for Structural Evaluation and Strengthening of Flexible Road Pavements Using Falling Weight Deflectometer”

2. IRC:SP:89-2018 (Part 1 & 2)
   “Guidelines for Construction of Cement Concrete Pavements”

3. IS 2720 (Various Parts)
   “Methods of Test for Soils”

   • Essential for subgrade soil testing.

4. IRC:SP:42-2014
   “Guidelines on Road Drainage”

   • Important for pavement durability and water management.

Additional Points Related to Pavements

• Subgrade Preparation: Both pavement types require proper preparation of the subgrade for performance and durability.
• Drainage Importance: Poor drainage can lead to premature failure in both types of pavement, especially flexible ones.
• Environmental Impact: Cement production has higher carbon emissions than bitumen, making flexible pavement slightly more eco-friendly.
• Noise Levels: Rigid pavement often produces more tyre noise than flexible pavement.
• Recyclability: Both types can be recycled. Bituminous materials are easier to reuse on-site.

Conclusion🎯

Choosing between flexible pavement and rigid pavement depends on several factors including traffic load, budget, construction time, and climate. Flexible pavement is economical and quicker to construct, making it suitable for most city and rural roads. On the other hand, rigid pavement offers longevity and strength, ideal for highways, airports, and industrial use.

FAQs on Pavement Types in Road Construction

Q1: Which pavement lasts longer?
Rigid pavement generally lasts longer than flexible pavement, with a lifespan of over 20 years.

Q2: Can flexible pavement be used for highways?
Yes, but it may require thicker layers and more frequent maintenance.

Q3: Which type is more eco-friendly?
Flexible pavement has a slightly lower environmental impact due to lower carbon emissions in bitumen production.

Q4: Is maintenance cost higher for flexible pavement?
Yes, it needs frequent patching, resurfacing, and crack sealing.

Other Important Articles for You